RSS Twitter Facebook YouTube
Expand Menu

2013 MLB Mock Draft 1.0

2013 MLB Mock Draft 1.0
April 7, 2013
Share via: Share: Facebook Share: Twitter Share: Google Share: Pinterest Share: Print Share: Email

The draft season is in full swing, and I find I am often getting more and more questions about who might go where and who is going to be around when the Indians pick. It seems like the right time of year to do my first mock. Since the Indians are picking in the top five this year, this mock will only go ten picks deep.  So this is more of a protected picks mock.

Here are my ground rules as a mocker, the pick is always what I think will happen. I pull up the teams recent draft history and see what would make the most sense. The point is to figure out how things will play out, not how I think they should play out. This explains why I just don't have the top players going in order.

1.Houston Astros - Jonathan Gray, RHP, Oklahoma

The last time a team had the first pick back to back the Nationals got Strasburg and Harper, so no matter what Houston does it won't be as good as the Nationals in the same situation. Last year's draft rules changed everything, and no one did a better job than Houston. I think right now there is a 1A and 1B for the top pitchers in this class, so I bet Houston plays them off each other and takes whoever signs for less so they can use this money later, which was their approach last year.  Gray is my favorite pitcher in this draft as what he can do makes me see a pitcher with true number one potential.  He shows two plus pitches, is a workhorse, and throws it harder than anyone. He can sustain this power and has even hit triple digits late in games.  In all fairness I would take Gray number one if I was running Houston, but I think it is also what they will do as I bet he will be cheaper than Appel.

2. Chicago Cubs - Mark Appel, RHP, Stanford

I think Appel could be a solid four or five starter in the majors this year. He should make the rotation of whatever team drafts him by next season, he is that ready. My scouting report on him last year is the same as this year as I see him as a very good number two type down the road. An All Star most years, but just shy of that elite upper tier. He has the lowest floor and a very high ceiling, and is the safest pick in this entire draft.  I just don't see a way the top two pitchers don't go one and two in the draft this year.

3. Colorado Rockies - Austin Meadows, OF, Grayson HS (Georgia)

The Rockies love to draft toolsy young players, and the most toolsy player in this draft is Meadows. He is a legitimate five tool talent who projects to stay in centerfield. The Rockies took David Dahl in the top ten last year, and Meadows projects to me as a better version of Dahl. Meadows has every tool you could want and would instantly be the Rockies number one prospect to me. He just fits their draft profile so well. There is talk they could move CarGo this year and Meadows would become the heir apparent even if he is years away.

4. Minnesota Twins - Jon Denney, C, Yukon HS (Oklahoma)

Denney is rising as fast as anyone in this draft. He plays a position of scarcity, but it's his power and bat speed that mean he would be a first rounder no matter of position. When you add in the fact he projects as an above average defensive catcher that is why Denney could easily go in the top five and should to me. You never draft for need, but if players are close then you should look at strengths and weakness of a system. Frazier is higher on my board, but only two spots higher. A team like Minnesota which has a lot of outfield depth, it makes sense to take Denney.  Frazier has the better bat, but Denney has a much greater positional value. At the end of the day, due to position, there is a much better chance that Denney is a top five player at his position than Frazier is when it's all said and done.

5. Cleveland Indians - Clint Frazier, OF, Loganville HS (Georgia)

Frazier is currently third on my board,  so why is he still here? The reason is position as he is projected to move to a corner outfield spot. This makes him a little less valuable than a sure centerfielder or catcher to many. The other issue is with his size and build that there might not be a ton of projection left in him. Yet when I see his bat speed, it makes me a believer. This kid can catch up to any pitch, and when there is a mistake he is going to hammer it. He doesn't have the tools of Meadows or the power of Bryant. I still think the Mike Trout comparison is unfair as he might be a once in a generation talent. If Frazier reminds me of anyone it is more David Wright. To me he is the top hitter in this draft and would give the Indians a fourth blue chip player in their system, which is something that has not happened since the early 90's.

6. Florida Marlins - Kris Bryant, 1B, San Diego State

Bryant is far and away the best college hitter in this draft. He has 70 level power in his future and should be in the top ten for homeruns every year. He is not just all power as he has good bat speed and a good eye and projects to be a three or four hitter very soon. He could put up MVP type numbers. The issue with him is position he plays third base but few think he can stick there. He played center field this year and no one thinks he can stick there either. He might be able stick as a corner outfielder, but it seems more than likely he ends up as a first baseman with questionable defense.  For those who are new to the baseball draft, first basemen are the guard equivalent of the NFL draft. They tend to fall just because of position. If Bryant played  an up the middle position or could even stick at third base, there is a good chance he goes number one or two.

7. Boston Red Sox - Kohl Stewart, RHP, St. Pious X (Texas)

Stewart is the last of the first tier of players to me in this draft. I really like him and view him as the top prep arm in this class. Saying that, he is barely in the upper tier to me and I debate back and forth on this. I don't like him as much as the top six but like him more than anyone after him by a good margin as well.  The first issue with Stewart is he is also a very good football player and is committed to Texas A&M to be their future quarterback someday soon. So whatever team takes the risk, they will have to realize he has all of the leverage. If Stewart is not a top 20 pick I doubt he ends up signing. This is also a positive for Stewart as a quarterback needs to have a strong arm and the ability to repeat their mechanics under the pressure of an opposing defense. Compared to this pitching might seem like a more relaxed activity. You have to love the athleticism and when you add the arm to that athleticism it is easy to see a potential ace. He is a ways away and needs to work on command like most young pitchers, but the upside is enough to intrigue some team in the top ten.

8. Kansas City - Sean Manaea, LHP, Indiana St.

Manaea was viewed as a sure top three pick before the year began, and even though he has been a major disappointment, there is no way he does not end up in the top ten. It can be hard to find a lefty who throws as hard as he does, and when you add in a slider that at one point looked like the top pitch in this draft, some team will take the chance sooner than later. If you have faith in your pitching coaches in the lower levels then you draft Manaea and figure they can fix him. He went to a smaller program and didn't have the same support the bigger programs have. He has the size and velocity every team wants.  He could be a front of the rotation pitcher, and at this point if you are going to take a pitcher from the second tier you might as well take the lefty with the best upside.

9. Pittsburgh Pirates - Braden Shipely, RHP, University of Nevada

Now might be a good time to talk about short sightedness. This is the pick Pittsburgh received for failing to sign Appel last year. Now, as an Indians fan, we should all be thankful for this because without this pick then the Mets are in the top ten and Michael Bourn signs with them before the Indians even enter the picture.  Yet, who would you rather have: Mark Appel and a year of seasoning readying to pitch in your majors this year along with Cole and Taillon? Or wait a year and get Braden Shipley and Colin Moran?  The Pirates were so afraid to lose a  pick they ended up with less talent this year. You need to be able to evaluate your own team, and this was a major failure to me. Appel  is head and shoulders above Shipley and keeping the 14th pick was not worth letting him walk. As for Shipley, he is a good pitcher and should be in the top ten as I see him as more of a three or four starter type. He has pitched well this year and sits in the mid 90's and has solid secondary offerings. It just seems a little less than spectacular when you compare him against Mark Appel.

10.  Toronto Blue Jays - Trey Ball, OF/LHP, New Castle HS (Indiana)

I was very tempted to put Ryan Boldt here, who I think is going to rise as the draft approaches.  I still ended up going with Trey Ball. Toronto loves to draft upside and athletes, and Ball is a great athlete who could have a major league future as a hitter or a pitcher. He is 6'6" which would lead a majority of teams to making him a pitcher, but it takes one team to like him as a hitter and he could stay there.  He is mostly projection at this point, and is a guy who will be drafted then should just be forgotten by fans for a few years so he can develop and fill out (he might be 6'6" but he is only 180 pounds). At this point, to me he has the best upside of any player on the board and his stock should only rise now that Indiana's high school baseball season has begun.

So there is my first mock of the year. With each new mock this year I will expand out on picks. This draft is not viewed as the strongest and with many of the top players underachieving like Stanek and Manaea or hurt like Austin Wilson, it has made it a year where a top ten pick might not have the value it traditionally has had in the past.

Yet this is an important draft for the Indians because it should be the last time they have a top five selection for a while.  This might be the last chance to grab a real blue chip type player for the foreseeable future. For me, I see six or maybe seven guys with probable All Star potential, and I am looking forward to the Indians adding another top prospect to a system which has been steadily improving.

If there  any questions please post them in the comments section and I will respond.

Follow Jeff on Twitter @jeffmlbdraft, or email him at

User Comments

April 8, 2013 - 11:33 AM EDT
I would definitely be excited by Stanek if he was the pick. He has that "ace" build.
April 8, 2013 - 9:13 AM EDT
Agreed, I think if Stanek is there at 5 he's the guy. I'd prefer him myself, perhaps over Appel. No way Gray falls to 5, IMO so ill defer. I simply choose Shipley as an example bc he's a hot name lately.

Btw, I don't think it's the right path to take targeting a specific spot (position) high, but I think they may look to infuse a cpl college arms into the SP rotation in the minors with hopes of hitting on a few.
April 7, 2013 - 10:45 PM EDT
I will say it again you dont force pitching. Manaea's value was based hugely on the cape I would not touch as velocity being down on a college kid scares the crap out of me.

As for Shipley I kind of like Blair from Marshall better.

There is a clear top 6 for me and to reach for a lesser guy is just foolish. This is not the NFL or NBA, these guys wont help for 2 to 4 years. You don't think about need, because by the time they are ready so much can happen. You take the top player and move on.

Will try and get my big board out in the next week, this was purely based on who seems to be rising.

I think if the Indians do draft a starter the most likely guy is still Stanek, had his issues but velocity has stayed the same, and 2 of last 3 starts solid
April 7, 2013 - 10:26 PM EDT
To me Shipley is being a little over rated here. He's a nice pitcher but I don't see him as superior to any number of college arms. Cederoth & Kubitza are as good IMO. Ziomek & Overton may be. Ben Lively from UCF has a 0.61 ERA & a sub 1.00 WHIP in 59 IP. Cederoth is actually a good comp.

I'd love to get Frazier & Denney would be a nice consolation prize. Unless, of course, Appel or Gray falls to us, In that case we take the pitcher.
April 7, 2013 - 8:29 PM EDT
I think we could see a college arm. Just speculation but I wouldn't rule out Braden Shipley at 5. I think it would be an over draft but he could potentially bring a quick return for the Tribe. It would be considered another Naquin pk by many but he can pitch and could get a bit stronger (bigger) physically. Although he is 6'3 190 now. Btw, Shipley hits mid - 90's and is rumored to have hit 99 a few times as well.
April 7, 2013 - 8:17 PM EDT
I hope Frazier is there and the pick. I don't trust the Tribe with drafting pitching in the first round at this point. Every live arm has turned into a reliever. IMO you do what you do best.
April 7, 2013 - 7:42 PM EDT
I say Frazier goes number 2 and Appel goes 3 or 4. I just hope we don't have another wild pick.
April 7, 2013 - 6:39 PM EDT
I didnt read your comment before making mine, Jeff... just curious, is there any way Manaea pitches himself back into top 5 contention in your eyes?
April 7, 2013 - 6:22 PM EDT
Pullin for Manaea to the tribe. Bauer/Manaea 1-2 in 2016 would be amazing
April 7, 2013 - 5:24 PM EDT
Never ever even consider need, doesnt matter the draft reaching for need is always folly. Look at the Pirates and what happens when you reach for a need at pitching. You take a top talent and they can always be traded later. Manaea would be a bad overdraft, not even a top ten talent to me
April 7, 2013 - 5:17 PM EDT
the point i was trying to make is best available talent for us may not fit this year do to the talent on board it is risky to draft for need however we can afford to take that risk;
April 7, 2013 - 5:10 PM EDT
ideally i would like to grab a left handed starting pitcher. I view farm systems a lil different that MLB does. The top two levels (AA & AAA) first tier-- A+ and A 2nd tier and the third tier is Extended the NYPA and rookie leagues on players either from the caribbean who need schooling. I rate the indians very high on tier 2 and tier 3 prospects (top 5+) so drafting for need is more acceptible. I am not sure i want the number 5 pic to augment a strength such as corner outfielder. however the fear i have with Manaea is to compare him even though lefthanded with the choice of Luke Holchever who never panned out or the guy from ball St that pittsburgh took who also never panned out when you take a guy that high is is triple pain to not get premier numbers from them. I think the royals may have taken Luke ahead of verlander if i remember correctly or that may have been bullinger i cant quite remember which stiff it was. To me you get a top 5 pick you turn it into perrenial all star. I am not sure any one in this draft outside of the two righthanders fits that description and appel and gray are gone at number 5. Maybe what is troubling manaea will correct itself and he pitches himself back up to top 5 pick. Regardless it is nice to have the talent oozing out of the system that we have.

Your Name:
Leave a Comment:
Security Code: