RSS Twitter Facebook YouTube
Expand Menu

IBI Power Poll: Which player makes the most impact in 2014?

Each player listed is either a potential rookie, or minor leaguer

IBI Power Poll: Which player makes the most impact in 2014?
November 11, 2013
Share via: Share: Facebook Share: Twitter Share: Google Share: Pinterest Share: Print Share: Email

Before we get started with our latest power poll, let me just take the time to honor all of those that have fought, or are fighting for our armed services. I can’t thank you enough for the freedom that you provide for us, the citizens of the United States of America. Too often, we get caught up in the ridiculousness and rigidness of politics, but the only reason why we can, is because of the brave men and women that provide us with that right every day.

Happy Veteran’s Day. It’s a small token, but know that I respect each and every one of you.

In our last power poll, I asked the readers of Indians Baseball Insiders what the front office would do with Scott KazmirUbaldo Jimenez and Justin Masterson over the offseason. It seems appropriate that we take a quick look at that poll before heading into our next one.

It’s rare that our polls ever hit a 50% majority, but this one was one not only crossed the line, but was a no-doubt-about it.

66% said that Chris Antonetti and the front office should ‘Sign Kazmir this year, then Masterson next year, and let Jimenez sign a crazy five-year deal elsewhere.’ The Indians have yet to sign any of the aforementioned starters, but news should begin matriculating sometime soon that Ubaldo Jimenez is officially a free agent.

That’s part one of the majority scenario.

Part two would be that the Indians sign lefty Scott Kazmir.

If you were to believe the rumors, the Indians aren’t likely to sign their ‘comeback player of the year’ because they are haggling over the years of the deal. Reportedly, the Indians want to sign Kaz to a one-year deal, while his agent is looking for a two-year deal.

If the Indians lose Kazmir over the years of the deal, and the years are one and two, then shame on them. Of course, rumors tend to be a little off-skew, so we’ll just have to wait and see.

Coming in at a distant second was for the Indians to ‘Go for broke, and sign Kazmir, Jimenez and Masterson’ for next season. That got a whopping 11% of the vote.

Nothing else had double-digit percentages.

It seems as though most Indians fans would like to see Kazmir and Masterson with the Indians this year and beyond, while Ubaldo Jimenez can take his mercurial self elsewhere.

Now onto our next Power Poll.

While the Indians will most certainly be attacking free agency in a similar manner as last year, it’s nearly impossible to figure out which direction they may ultimately go.

Chris Antonetti made note that the Indians were going to be looking for bullpen help and for a left-handed hitter, it’s relatively clear that he’s maintaining the CIA-like stance in information giving. Since Mark Shapiro became the GM over ten years ago, the Indians’ front office has rarely given the media any sign of the direction that they are really going, and often give out misleading information.

You can see it from top to bottom in several interviews that Shapiro, Antonetti, John Mirabelli and Ross Atkins give. If you ask them about a specific player’s skills, you get a fountain of fantastic information. If you ask them about a general question about how teams handle free agency, salary or the like, they are equally giving with the information. But if you try to pin them down on what the club may be doing in the future, let’s just say that it turns into story time at the corner of Carnegie and Ontario.

That’s the way it should be.

With that said, it’s time to take a look at the players that are already in the Indians’ organization, while we wait to see how some things shake out here at the beginning of the Hot Stove Season.

Last season, several youngsters made an impact for the Indians throughout the season that were either rookies, or surprises from the minor league system. Corey Kluber and Yan Gomes were the two biggest names that many of us thought were going to spend the majority of the season in the minors, me included.

There were several others that came on to make different levels of positive influence on the team as well and some of them are going to mentioned in this week’s power poll for next year.

Today’s Power Poll is going to focus on ‘Which current members of the Indians’ organization who are either rookies or minor leaguers could make the biggest impact on the 2014 season?’

What's my criteria? The players listed below all spent significant time in the minor leagues in 2013. They were either climbing the ladder as prospects, injured and didn't play, then lost their jobs, or just plain lost their jobs. I may not hit everyone that could make an impact

Here’s the list, as it stands today:

  • Jose Ramirez: 2B, SS—I make absolutely no qualms in saying that Jose Ramirez is better than most folks give him credit for. In my first year covering the Indians for IBI, I was lucky enough to talk to Tom Hamilton for a few minutes just prior to the season, and I asked him how I should evaluate what the Indians’ front office says. He smiled and said, ‘Trust what you see, not necessarily what you hear. If it walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it must be a duck.’ Jose Ramirez is a duck, or in this case, a highly valued piece ofTerry Francona’s puzzle. Will he start the year off with the Indians? Will he be a utility player or something more? Will he allow the Indians to make a move, or will he be part of a trade? It’s all unknown right now, but I get the sense that Terry Francona loves JRam, and will be doing whatever he can to get him in the lineup.
  • Trevor Bauer: SP—Trevor Bauer is an enigma, wrapped in a riddle. Whenever you mention his name, the first thing that you likely think of are his eccentricities on and off the mound. You think of Bauer throwing long toss, from foul-to-foul pole. You think of Happy Gilmore, when he steps behind the mound before warming up, and fires the ball towards his catcher at mach 10. If you don’t care about the workout regimen, you may ponder his dreadful appearances with the Indians in 2013. In 17 innings pitched in four starts, he gave up 10 earned runs, while walking 16, and striking out eleven. His 5.29 ERA wasn’t horrible, but you have to be a bit concerned about his 16 walks. You also have to be a bit concerned about the fact that the Indians have seemed to allow Bauer the right to control the changes to his mechanics. Will it all click for the former top pitching prospect in baseball, or is it all over for him?
  • Lou Marson: C—Okay, so Marson isn’t really a minor leaguer, and I really have no clue with what the Indians intend to do with him, now that Yan Gomes isn’t going away any time soon. Marson still may have a shot at the big league club, however, should there be injury issues, a trade, or if Carlos Santana makes a more substantial move to first base and DH next year. If that’s the case, might Marson find his way back to Cleveland as a capable back-up?
  • Scott Barnes: RP, SP—Barnes used to be a highly thought of lefty starter, but he just couldn’t seem to be able to take the next step, so the Indians moved him to the pen. Now he’s a lefty reliever. Rich Hill proved last year that you didn’t have to be all that good to be a lefty in the bullpen. Could Barnes be Rich Hill? Alright, that wasn’t very nice to either player, so let me rephrase. Could Scott Barnes do enough in spring training to take over Rich Hill’s role in the pen?
  • Preston Guilmet: RP—One of the most interesting watches for the Indians in 2014 will be the back-end of the bullpen. Preston Guilmet has one of the most interesting resumes available heading into next season. He’s been a closer for much of his career in the minors, and his overall line is impressive. He’s 18-14, with a 2.57 ERA in nearly 300 innings of minor league ball. He’s struck out 324 batters, while walking only 64. He’s efficient, and he generally confines his mistakes to one outing, thanks to the perfect bullpen mentality. Now, he did struggle in his stint with the Indians, but when you make one appearance in July, one in August, one on September 2 and one on September 12, I don’t think that’s a fantastic indicator. Could he fill right in for Joe Smith thanks to that deceptive delivery?
  • Carlos Carrasco: RP, SP—Chris Antonetti said that Carrasco was going to get every opportunity to be a starter. Okay, I don’t think he’s lying or anything, but I have to believe that there have been discussions to test him out on a full-time basis in the pen going forward. Of course, if the Indians fail to sign Kazmir or Ubaldo, they may have to use Carrasco in the rotation. Even if they do, there’s not indicator to think that his head can be right over the long haul. He was good in the pen though. Might this be his year…finally?
  • Nick Hagadone: RP—I really shouldn’t put Hagadone here, because common sense would tell you that he’s next in line for the lefty relief role. Of course, the electric-armed reliever has closer stuff, but can’t ever seem to put it all together at the big league level. There’s clearly an opening behind Mark Rzepczynski. The question is, can he finally grab it?
  • C.C. Lee: RP—If it weren’t for Tommy John surgery in 2012, CC Lee would have been a major piece to the bullpen in 2013. The injury put him a year behind, but he did show up as a bit player late in the year. He made eight appearances. Three of them came in July, and he pitched two innings, without giving up a hit. He returned in September, and struggled a bit at times, but still didn’t lose the luster of being perhaps the best minor league bullpen arm in the system. Lee has all the moxie and all the stuff to be good, now he just needs the experience.
  • Vinnie Pestano: RP—What can you say about Pestano right now? With Perez and Joe Smith gone, it’s clear that the Tribe NEEDS him to return to 2012 form. Will he, or will arm trouble and scuffling be the end of his days of dominance? If Pestano can find it again, he’s immediately the closer. If he can’t, he may not even make the team.
  • Josh Tomlin: SP, RP—Let’s face it. When you mention the starting pitching candidates, nobody really thinks Josh Tomlin is going to be the #5 starter. Like many before him (Jeremy SowersAaron LaffeyDavid Huff…I know, Tomlin’s not a lefty…but you get my point), Tomlin doesn’t seem to have the velocity to be taken seriously. Still, he has a high IQ, is tenacious, and always seemed to find a way. If the flash-and-bank of Bauer and Carrasco whimper in 2014, can Tomlin steal their thunder?
  • Colt Hynes: RP—Hynes is an unknown commodity right now, but as a left-handed reliever, he could be a guy that’s in the mix right away.  He was mostly a reliever in the minors, and if you take away his 126 1/3 innings as a starter, his 3.59 ERA drops under 3 for his career out of the pen. In his lone time in the bigs, he gave up 17 earned runs in 17 innings of work. No, it’s not impressive, but as “Scrabble” can tell you, sometimes a change of scenery and steady work is all it takes.
  • Blake Wood: RP—Wood has some pedigree, as he was a former third rounder of the Kansas City Royals. He can’t be a free agent until 2017, but he doesn’t have any options left, and he can’t seem to find the strike zone. He can bring it, but until he finds it, he may not even be with the club through spring training. If he somehow makes it through though, he has the type of arm that could be special. There’s a long way from here to there though.
  • Matt Capps: RP—Capps signed a minor league deal with the Indians, after doing the same at the start of 2013. Injuries kept him down in 2013, but with Chris Perez and Joe Smith gone, and with no clear closer available, can Matt Capps become a factor in 2014? Many scouts believe that Capps should have never been a closer to begin with, but perhaps there is more there than meets the eye. If he can stay healthy, he’ll have a shot to make this team in the Matt Albers role.
  • Giovanni Soto: RP—Most people forget that Soto was the guy the Indians got back for Jhonny Peralty. Most people forget that Soto threw a no-hitter for the Indians organization as a starter. Heck, most people forget that Soto is with the team. Why mention him with all his health issues? He’s a lefty, and he can be really, really good.
  • Bryan Price: RP—Price is the unknown that came over from the Victor Martinez trade, and while he doesn’t grade at the top of the bullpen arms that the Indians currently have, he was pretty good in 2013. Some like him a whole lot better than I do as a major league reliever, but with the fluidity of the bullpen, he could be a factor.
  • T.J. House: SP—House is one of my favorite stories in the Indians organization. He was stuck in High A Kinston/Carolina for 2 ½ seasons. After his second full year at High A though, things changed. House took getting healthy seriously, and came into camp in the best shape of his life. He’s been a different player since. He dominated in Carolina to start the year, then finished strong in Akron in 2012. He started off the year back in Akron, but after pitching well in April, made the jump to Columbus. He didn’t dominate, but he did go 7-10 with a 4.32 ERA. He struck out 137, while walking only 57, and he has better velocity as a lefty than people think. I don’t think he’s quite ready, but he’s only 24-years old, and if he starts out with some good starts in Triple A, he could be up sooner than folks think.
  • Tyler Holt: CF—According to Tony Lastoria, Tyler Holt is the best defender in the entire Indians’ system.  I don’t disagree with that at all. Holt is a kid that continually gets better as he rises through the system. There’s nothing that stands out, other than his tenacity and that defense, but he could be a bona fide fourth or fifth outfielder, should the need arise.
  • Jesus Aguilar: 1B—There’s a lot of buzz about Aguilar, and this will happen when there is a sieve in the system for power hitting, corner position players. Not much has changed with regards to Aguilar over the years. He has good power when he isn’t striking out. He can drive in some runs, and he is improving year-to-year. The Indians could certainly use some cost-effective power, and Aguilar would certainly be that. Will this be his year, or is he a year away?
  • Carlos Moncrief: RF—Tic…Tic…Tic…BOOM!! Moncrief had a really nice year in 2013, and the upside is impressive. He had an .824 OPS in a pitcher’s league and managed to strike out less than 100 times for the first time in his full-season career. I believe he’ll play a full season in Columbus but if his numbers continue to improve, and there’s no reason to think they won’t, he could be a legitimate major league candidate at some point in 2014, and for sure in 2015. There’s 20-20 potential there, but has to maintain his progression.
  • Chun-Hsiu Chen: DH—If he were still a catcher, I’d say there was a shot, but he just isn’t a great hitter, and as a DH-only, he’s about to get swept up by a slew of prospects heading for Columbus. Let’s face it…I put Chen in here for my good buddy, Steve Orbanek.
  • Francisco Lindor: SS—If it weren’t for the back injury that ended his Double A stint a bit short, I’d have Lindor at the top of my list. He’s really…really good. How much better than JRam is he? I actually think there is some question there. No, I’m not saying JRam is better, but I am saying there can be a conversation about it. Look, Lindor is the shortstop of the future, but JRam is valued, and really good. With that said, as soon as Lindor is ready, and as soon as the shortstop position is open, the job is Lindor’s. If he’s healthy and hitting, it’ll be sooner, rather than later. If he needs time to take back, it’ll be after July. Either way, I think we see Lindor in 2014.
  • Tyler Naquin: RF/CF—I only throw Naquin in here because of something Jeff Ellis said right after they drafted Naquin. On a Smoke Signals, Ellis said that Naquin would be propelled through the system and be knocking at the Indians door in 2013, and earlier than most people think. Ellis pointed to his plus bat, and his plus defense. For one thing or another, that didn’t pan out. Naquin ended up in Double A last year, but you do have to wonder what the Indians think about him overall. Can he make the move after his nice performance in Fall ball, and a strong start to 2013? Perhaps the answer is yes. There’s a lot that likely still needs to be worked out, but there is some pedigree there, right? 
  • Kyle Crockett: RP--Crockett was a fourth rounder in 2013, and zoomed quickly through the system. The Indians moved him from Mahoning to Lake County to Akron, and he excelled at all three places. He's another lefty, and while his stuff isn't electric like Cody Allen's, he has serious skills. He has the poise you want in a reliever, and can control the strike zone. His fast ball is a low-90's offering that he can locate well, as well as a nice slider and curve. Is he special? There's not enough of a sample size, but so far, so good.

There are your choices. If I forgot one or two, I apologize, but mention them in the comments, and I’ll add them to the list, if there hasn’t been too many votes as of yet. Happy Veteran’s Day, and happy voting.

You are allowed two votes:


Jim is currently the senior editor and Columnist, as well as  the host of IBI's weekly online radio shows, Smoke Signals and Cleveland Sports Insiders. You can follow Jim on Twitter @Jim_IBI, or contact him via e-mail at

User Comments

November 12, 2013 - 8:02 AM EST
I think both Blake Wood and Carlos Carrasco are out of options... That's two interesting arms IF they can get it together. I think Wood has a legit chance to make the pen. Carrasco will get a look as a SP but I think he opens with the big club as a long reliever.

Jose Ramirez offers an interesting table setter to the lineup. His speed, defense and on base ability could impact the lineup. I think he's more than a UTL player despite his size and lack of power. That said, it appears Lindor will be the future at SS.

I've been a fan of Trevor Bauer for several yrs, but honestly I don't know what to think about him... He could be the biggest wild card in the org. IF he gets it together he could have a Danny Salazar type impact on the rotation.
November 11, 2013 - 11:16 PM EST
Interesting poll and responses. What I find interesting is some of the comments and some of the guys picked. Amazes how some perceive guys who really are not that valued by the org or in the industry....or have limited chances to be a factor next season. One of the neat things to see because it just shows how every fan views things differently.
November 11, 2013 - 11:04 PM EST
I went with Pestano and Carrasco. Both will have more chances at the Major league level than any of the others besides maybe Tomlin or Ramirez.

Let's not forget Pestano was an absolute beast prior to last year and despite his lack of velocity, he still struck out 9.4 per 9. I think he's got as good of a chance of a comeback season as Asdrubal.

Carrasco is going to have a huge season, just watch.
November 11, 2013 - 8:58 PM EST
It amazes me that Scott Barnes gets swept under the carpet so quickly. He was cruising along until the knee injury set him back. His fastball hits 94. His slider is filthy and he'll throw a nasty changeup in any count. If they waste time trying to make him a loogy, it would be nothing short of stupid. With that said I picked Carrasco and Ramirez. Both have high ceilings and the potential talent to be game changers.
November 11, 2013 - 5:18 PM EST
I picked Jose Ramirez. I see Asdrubal being traded and I think Tito likes the versatility Aviles provides and not pencil him in as his everyday shortstop So I look for Ramirez to open the season at shortstop
November 11, 2013 - 4:35 PM EST
Bauer and Lee
November 11, 2013 - 3:52 PM EST
Went with Bauer and Price. I have feeling Bauer will turn things around 14. I think Price will surprise people and the last piece from the VMart trade will contribute to the Indians bullpen.
November 11, 2013 - 2:24 PM EST
I went Jesus Aguliar and Carassco. I don't see the playing time for Ramirez and I think the Indians are going to rely on Aguilar's bat and I think Carassco will beat out whomever for the last spot in the rotation
November 11, 2013 - 12:24 PM EST
I obviously picked JRam, and also picked Trevor Bauer...

I'm a hopeful guy...
November 11, 2013 - 12:23 PM EST
If it were up to me Tony, I'd give everyone two choices, and only one option...

Jose Ramirez.

Michael, your pin is in the mail...
November 11, 2013 - 12:02 PM EST
I want a J-Ram campaign pin.
November 11, 2013 - 11:46 AM EST
Damn you Jim, you put too many guys so it made it tough to even pick two.;)

In any case, when you look at that list you can see where the Indians have a lot of depth in the bullpen with righties and lefties....and they have some good depth in the middle infield, outfield and first base which very little as far as a long term commitment goes should be made this offseason.

Where they lack depth and true options is at third base and starting pitching, and that is where I expect them to spend most of their money. Trevor Bauer has a great opportunity to impact the club in 2014 because of that, but because his 2013 was so poor the organization lost some confidence in him and will go into 2014 with him set to open at Columbus and be a depth starter. So it was tough for me to pick him as an impact guy for 2014 in the short term....though believe long term he definitely can be at some point.

I went with the bullpen guys Lee and Crockett. I believe Lee opens the year in Cleveland and might have a Pestano-like jump in responsibility (a la 2011). He is an important pen arm to build on as he is the best reliever in the system. I also selected Crockett as he should move through Akron and Columbus quickly and assume a lefty role by midseason sort of like Cody Allen in 2012, if not quicker.

Guys like Aguilar, Moncrief, Naquin, Lindor and Ramirez should all impact at some point in their careers, but I see the opportunities to impact being limited in 2014 unless injuries crop up. All should spend most if not all of the year in the minors, or in a guy like Ramirez's case, possibly as a bench option.
November 11, 2013 - 11:31 AM EST
If Ramirez isn't traded, I think he could impact the lineup with his speed, defense and on base ability.

Now that he's healthy Blake Wood should be ready to step into one of the bullpens slots.

Kyle Crockett seems primed to make a splash as a legit LHRP mid-summer.
November 11, 2013 - 11:22 AM EST
Remember, I gave everyone two votes, since there are so many legit choices...
November 11, 2013 - 11:21 AM EST
The most interesting part of this poll is the simple fact that there really are a bunch of names that could have impact. Sure, a bunch of them are relievers, but it does show the growing depth of the system. There aren't many impact guys, but there are some good players, and some sleepers...



I'd make campaign pins if I had the time...
November 11, 2013 - 11:13 AM EST
I went with Bauer. He's got the talent and expect him to hold down a #4 or #5 spot.

I think Lindor will make a cameo appearance in September (maybe a little earlier). I don't see a spot in the regular line-up for J-Ram. I do see Crocket taking a BP spot early next year and making a significant contribution.

Your Name:
Leave a Comment:
Security Code:

IBI Videos

No videos at this time

Available IBI Books

The 2014 Cleveland Indians Baseball Insider book featuring the Indians' Top 100 Prospects and more is now available. Also, previous editions from 2008-2012 are also available at a discounted rate. Just click on the book image for more information. Thanks again for all the support!


RSS Twitter Facebook YouTube
News   |   Teams   |   Players   |   Reference   |   Rankings   |   Depth Chart   |   Payroll   |   Privacy
Admin Login
All Rights Reserved 2016, Indians Baseball Insider   |   Affordable web design by Alt Media Studios