RSS Twitter Facebook YouTube
Expand Menu

Second Thoughts: Game #46 - White Sox 12, Indians 6

Second Thoughts: Game #46 - White Sox 12, Indians 6
May 27, 2012
Share via: Share: Facebook Share: Twitter Share: Google Share: Pinterest Share: Print Share: Email
  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 R H E
CLE 0 3 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 6 12 0
CWS 3 0 1 3 3 0 0 2 X 12 15 1
W: Floyd (4-5) L: Jimenez (5-4)

The Indians limped into the 96-degree series finale against the White Sox just trying to avoid a sweep. Between having Ubaldo Jimenez on the hill against a surging lineup and their own still severely lacking due to a multitude of injuries, it was a tall task from the gate. Once again, the undermanned group competed early on, but poor pitching and not enough firepower buried them again.

The Good

Jason Kipnis continued to terrorize his hometown team with two more hits. Equally as impressive was the play he made in the bottom of the first inning. Paul Konerko flared a base hit over his head with the bases loaded and no one out. A run scored, but Kipnis tracked down the ball and was able to force Adam Dunn out at second base. Not ultimately much of a difference-maker in a six-run game, but it displayed the kind of player that he is. Most guys just wouldn't have thought or tried hard enough to get an out in such a situation. Over the three-game series, he went 6-for-12 with two runs scored, two home runs, four runs batted in, a walk and two stolen bases.

Johnny Damon came into this game 12-for-22 against White Sox starter Gavin Floyd. Despite his abysmal results at the plate thus far with the Indians, he was able to continue that success by depositing his first home run of the season. Count me out as someone who expects this to be a building block for him.

Michael Brantley put together a two-hit performance, and drove in two runs. It was the third multi-hit game during his current six-game hit streak. He continues to put the ball in play, produce well enough on both sides of the ball and look unflappable while doing it. There are holes in his game, but just so much to like.

Juan Diaz collected not only his first career Major League hit, but his second, as well. He was also hit by a pitch, and managed to reach base four times in nine plate appearances in the series.

The Bad

With this 12-6 loss, the Indians were outscored 35-16 in the series. Beyond that, they were outhit 42-25, and struck out 24 times compared to just four walks. The team has been great at walking and avoiding strikeouts so far this season, but without the services of their three, four and five hitters, the trend was bucked.

Jose Lopez scratched out his first hit since being thrown into the cleanup spot out of desperation (1-for-13), but he has obviously been trying too hard to live up to the designation. After settling into everyday playing time and comfortability, this series was full of poor swings and pitch recognition from him.

Shin-Soo Choo was held hitless for just the second time since moving to the leadoff spot. Two at-bats came against left-handed relievers, putting him at 6-for-50 on the season against southpaws.

Jairo Asencio was absolutely maimed for a second consecutive day. He gave up four extra base hits (and hit a batter) to the tune of three runs in his first inning of work, and wore it for another inning because of the short outing by Jimenez. His time with the Indians may very soon be up.

Tony Sipp had a 1-2-3 seventh inning, but labored through the eighth and was charged with two runs on a base hit that Joe Smith allowed. Sipp isn't really someone who should be going more than one inning, but the bullpen had a lot of mopping up to do in this one and Manny Acta tried to stretch him out.

The box score will show zero runs next to Smith's name, but he still gave up the hit. It was his second troublesome appearance in as many days.

One of three batters to get hit in this game (Casey Kotchman twice), Lou Marson took a breaking ball to the face in the fourth inning. It busted his lip open, but he stayed in the game until the score got out of hand later on. Three stitches were required to close the wound, but he doesn't expect to miss a game. With one catcher already down, thank goodness the results weren't drastically worse.

The Ugly

This is reserved for a single player.

Once again, Ubaldo Jimenez made Chris Antonetti and the Indians' brass look silly. He suffered through a disastrous first inning, in which nearly everything was either a bad miss or something up for the White Sox to drive. He made better pitches for a short time after that, but just can never seem to go without laboring through an inning. He fell apart for the last time with two outs in the fourth, an inning that was capped off by a three-run homer on an awful 3-2 hanger to Paul Konerko. In the end, he was responsible for seven runs, and again walked more (four) than he struck out (three). He threw 99 pitches, and Chicago hitters cut and missed at just five. It is also worth noting that Jimenez was checked on by trainer Lonnie Soloft on two separate occasions early on, but he stayed in the game. Any ailment plaguing Jimenez is likely not physical.

The Indians return home after this one with the hope that Asdrubal Cabrera and Travis Hafner will be available to them at some point during the series against Kansas City. It will take longer to get Carlos Santana back, but the team can ill-afford to be without all three any longer. A roster move will have to be made in order to active Josh Tomlin.

User Comments

May 29, 2012 - 8:47 AM EDT
The Indians went for quantity over quality by brining in bodies like Cunningham, Spilborghs and Pie. I did not expect any of them to make a meaningful contribution. I'd like to see Crowe out there as a 4th OF and the Tribe jettison Cunningham, Duncan and Damon.

It was short-sighted to say the least to start the season with the black hole in LF. Another problem that everyone could see (except for management) was the vulnerability to left handed pitching.

The annual injury bug is killing this team and they will have to change their S&C program and stay away from players who break down.
May 28, 2012 - 8:13 PM EDT
SgtCarter, not sure what else you can do about depth. They signed 8 bazillion guys to minor league deals in the offseason. They have depth, but unfortunately, there is absolutely no way no matter how much depth you sign that you can prepare for the loss of your 3-4-5 combo. I have no problem with the way they approached adding depth, but I do have a problem with how they did not get a much needed starter in LF.
May 28, 2012 - 8:10 PM EDT
The injuries are hurting the team. The veteran guys Hafner, Sizemore, Hannahan are on the DL every year. Now younger players like Brantley, Choo, Cabrera are doing the same thing. One breakdown factor for the older guys may be too many years on the juice, but the young guys shouldn't be pulling hammies, obliques etc. Perhaps they need a younger drill sergeant type trainer. Soloff may know a lot but it doesn't matter if he can't get them to put in the stretching, flexibility and strength training time every day. These players get paid a lot- up front, and whether they're hurt or not. It's too easy to slip thru the training cracks, and the next thing you know you pull a muscle running the bases or throwing a pitch, which is mostly avoidable. That's why you have to have a tough guy paying attention and getting in their faces every day.
May 28, 2012 - 12:46 PM EDT
What have Dolan, Shapiro and Antonetti done to improve the depth on this team when (not if) injuries occur? ZIp, zero, zilch.
May 28, 2012 - 11:42 AM EDT
That's a good point. Jiminez is a flop, which surprises no one that watched him last year in Colorado. Another brain dead heaver, Caribbean style. I would give his rotation spot to McCallister. He's a better pitcher right now, and he's coming up where Jiminez is going the other way. The argument that they can't demote, trade or release him because of his contract doesn't wash with me. Just because a player is hurting you at the bank, doesn't mean you have to let him hurt you on the field. And parting ways w Jiminez will be a redemptive move for Antonetti. He made a mistake, that's cool. Learn from it, move on.
May 28, 2012 - 3:23 AM EDT
Look for an fungus-infected toe nail, anything, and put this guy on the DL.
Give him a few days (or weeks) off, then let him rehab in A ball.
He is NOT at this point, a professional pitcher.
The Indians should have gone all-out to get Miguel Cabrera two years ago, but Adam Dunn was a necessity.
Dunn had one of the worst years a hitter has ever had in 2011, but has hit 15 HR's in 160+ AB's this year.
More importantly, he makes everybody in the lineup better even if he hits only .150 because pitchers fear him.
Big-Ugly-Guy in the lineup paid off for Mays, Mantle, Aaron, and we need our McCovey, Moose or Maris, & Mathews or Big Joe Adcock to intimidate.
Until we get that intimidator, we will never know how good our young players can be.

Your Name:
Leave a Comment:
Security Code: