RSS Twitter Facebook YouTube
Expand Menu

Spring Training Notebook: The Swisher surge

Spring Training Notebook: The Swisher surge
March 8, 2013
Share via: Share: Facebook Share: Twitter Share: Google Share: Pinterest Share: Print Share: Email

The Spring Training season is officially two weeks old, and the Cleveland Indians are sitting pretty with a 10-5 record, which is good for third place in the Cactus League. 10-5. Pretty nice, eh? But what exactly does it mean?

For most, the answer is simple — nothing.

Yes, the record does literally mean nothing. Spring Training wins do not transfer to the regular season, and they should not be looked at as a predictor of success.

However, I have a different take. Last season, the Indians’ record in Spring Training was 7-22. 7-22!?!?!? It was the worst record in either the Cactus League or Grapefruit League.

Also, the top six teams in terms of winning percentage from last year’s Spring Training averaged 84.5 wins during the regular season. Again, that hardly guarantees regular season success, but it does show that most of last season’s top Spring Training teams finished at least .500.

The bottom line is that while the Indians’ spring success may ultimately mean very little, would you rather the team perform in the opposite direction?

Winning on all levels is a good thing, and that’s exactly what the Indians are doing. Teammates are learning more and more about one another each day and best of all, they’re enjoying success — together. Spring Training or not, the value of that cannot be understated.

With that said, let’s take a look back at the week that was for the Cleveland Indians…

Player of the Week

Nick Swisher — 4 G, 9-for-11, 3 HR, 1 2B, 9 RBI, 2 BB, 1 K

Now this is what you call a nice four-game stretch. Swisher was just brilliant this past week as he only went hitless in two at-bats. For the spring season, Swisher is hitting .524, which only trails Ryan Raburn and Michael Brantley.  Swisher’s spring statistics only mean so much, but let’s hope this is a good sign as the season approaches. As everyone knows, Swisher is going to be asked to take on a much larger role than the one he was previously accustomed to with the New York Yankees. So far, it seems as if Swisher has embraced the challenge, and his bat seems to indicate that as well.

News & notes

— Speaking of Michael Brantley, it appears as if the outfielder could return to the Indians’ lineup sometime this weekend, possibly Sunday. Brantley was spiked back on Feb. 25 in a game against Oakland, and the injury required that he receive 15 stitches in his left forearm. The stitches were finally removed Thursday, and Brantley is practicing once again. It would be nice to see him return to the lineup because the left-handed hitter had gotten off to a strong start, going 5-for-6 with four doubles in three games. With all of the team’s new acquisitions, Brantley could be poised for a huge year this season, so let’s hope he returns to the lineup soon and gets plenty of at-bats before Opening Day.

— Brantley is not the only Indian working his way back from injury. Shortly after last week’s Spring Training Notebook was posted, it was announced that Chris Perez had a shoulder strain and would be out for three to four weeks. It’s the second straight Spring Training that Perez has dealt with an injury as the right-hander suffered a strained left side muscle last spring. Because of the injury, Perez was forced to miss the World Baseball Classic. The positive news is that Perez has not been ruled out of Opening Day, and he could start a throwing program as early as Sunday. However, he is still not expected to pitch in games for another few weeks after that point, so his chances of being on the Opening Day roster seem to becoming slimmer and slimmer by the day.

Ubaldo Jimenez had a very strong performance on Thursday as the often-erratic right-hander was under control and allowed three hits, one earned run and struck out two in four innings of work. The solid outing follows a performance in which Jimenez was rocked for seven hits and five earned runs in two innings. So, what can we make of Jimenez’s latest outing? It sure seems eerily familiar to the pattern Jimenez followed during the regular season last year where he had one good outing followed up by a stinker. Many fans are hoping that Jimenez is just outright released come late spring/early summer, but that type of thinking seems ludicrous to me. What type of Indians fan would want to see Jimenez fail? If he does indeed get released this season, it only means the Indians are struggling and obviously not doing very well. Instead, as the IBI’s Jim Pete eloquently pointed out in Wednesday’s Corner of Carnegie and Ontario, we all need to support Jimenez and hope for the best. It may still seem unlikely that he has success this year, but we have to hope. That makes plenty more sense than just cheering for the guy to fail. It’s far too early to call Thursday’s start the beginning of a consistent Jimenez, but with each solid outing, fans should slowly once again start to have faith in the right-hander.

— Many have questioned whether Jason Giambi still has the ability to hit a baseball, but don’t look now, the 42-year-old is on a two-game hit streak and launched a home run on Thursday. Giambi has gone 3-for-16 overall this spring, so the numbers still leave an awful lot to be desired. However, it seems as if he is a near-lock to make this team, and that may not necessarily be a bad thing. I can be counted among the concerned fans that question whether Giambi can still hit, but I realize that I need to take a step back and objectively look at what Giambi’s role will be on this team. Yes, he will certainly spell Mark Reynolds at times at designated hitter and probably face some tough right-handers, but his main role is to serve as a leader in the clubhouse. At his age and with his experience, Giambi is really like another coach, and it seems like it’s a role he relishes. Young hitters like Lonnie Chisenhall and Jason Kipnis can learn a great deal from the former slugger, and my feelings on Giambi are quickly changing.

— Ryan Raburn had another solid week and has now gone 11-for-20 this spring with two doubles, four home runs and 11 RBI. The IBI’s Charlie Adams wrote an excellent, detailed piece on Raburn this week. Adams provided some great, detailed statistics as to why Raburn could continue to have success provided he puts the ball into the air. It seems as if Raburn is almost a near-lock to make the Indians out of Spring Training and I, like many other fans, am okay with that. Raburn’s career has a been a mixed bag of good and bad, so let’s just hope the Indians happen to get some of the good.

— First baseman Mike McDade and Chris McGuiness have each played in the most Spring Training games for the Indians so far as each player has appeared in 13 contests. The two players’ last names also both start with “Mc.” However, that’s where the similarities end for these two players this spring. McDade has taken full advantage of his opportunity and has gone 9-for-22 with two doubles, a home run and nine RBI. In comparison, McGuiness has gone 3-for-22 with zero RBI. The sample sizes are still incredibly small, but that does not change the fact that McGuiness has been very underwhelming. There’s still plenty of time for him to rebound, but he better start quick or the Rule 5 Draft pick could find himself back with the Texas Rangers. McDade, on the other hand, likely has no chance of making the Indians’ Opening Day roster, but he has put himself in a good position to be one of the first players called up from Triple-A Columbus.

Quick hits

Vinnie Pestano and Team USA play their first World Baseball Classic game tonight ay 9 p.m. against Mexico as part of Pool D. Pestano seems pretty fired up to have the opportunity to be a part of Team USA, so let’s hope the right-hander manages to put up some good performances.

Frank Herrmann has been shut down because of a sprained ligament, but he is apparently scheduled head to New York to meet Dr. David Altchek, who has most recently worked with pitchers Johan Santana and Mariano Rivera. It’s unfortunate that Herrmann had the injury issue flare up when it did as he seemed as if he could be well on his way to being a more than capable middle reliever after his strong finish last season.

Steve can be reached via email at

User Comments

March 9, 2013 - 12:54 AM EST
I agree with Seth 100%
March 8, 2013 - 6:21 PM EST
I think Indians fans "who want Ubaldo to fail" are pretty much mythical. Wanting him to be released and wanting him to fail are not the same thing. If you want him to be released, it's because you figure he's a lost cause and will do increasing damage to the team the more he pitches: it's not "wanting him to fail", it's that he has already failed, and that the likes of Carrasco or Bauer are probably better options at this point.

They are obviously going to give Ubaldo a chance to turn it around, and they should (largely because Carrasco and Bauer have just as big of questions marks, and there are good reasons to hold both of them out at the beginning of the year), but based on the last 1.5 years of performance, wanting to release Ubaldo is perfectly understandable, and a decent argument could be made for it.
March 8, 2013 - 4:01 PM EST
I just don't understand Indians fans who want Ubaldo to fail. It seems like they are more concerned with being able to say "I told you so" then having a good ballclub this year. Honestly, I wouldn't call them "Indians fans" at all.

Ryan Raburn is such a solid pickup. Along with Mike Aviles it gives us two guys who can move all over the diamond makng sure everyone is rested and protected. I think Raburn can get a decent amount of PAs this season by spelling Chiz, Kipnis, Brantley and Stubbs as well as pinch hitting. Might be one of the best moves we made this offseason. Having a great bench is very underrated in the MLB.

Seeing Chisenhall and Brantley getting off to good starts is huge. Both this guys could help put the offense over the top this season from a "solid" offense to a "great" offense.

Also, such a huge "relief" to see reliever Nick Hagadone standing up and saying "I deserve a bullpen spot". Left handed pitching was one the area we failed to improve on this offseason. I really really really wanted the team to sign Tom Gorzelanny. It just would have made sense, but its nice to see Hagadone doing so well. Hopefully Barnes, Huff or Hill can claim the second spot in the BP.

My "perfect" offseason would have been very close to the offseason we actually had with a couple additions.

1. Tom Gorzelanny. Would have been a perfect addition to the BP mafia.

2. Chris Young. More starting pitching is always weclome on this team and he has I think THE BEST flyball to groundball ratio in the ML. Would have been a low risk high reward signing with out GG caliber outfield.

3. Signed another LH bat. This one I am a little unsure about since I think Giambi can be this seasons "Trot Nixon". But, perhaps signing a guy like Raul Ibanez or Luke Scott to pinch hit and spell Reynolds and Stubbs would have been more effective. Still, this is a small one and not that big a deal.

4. Wait until Kyle Lohse understands no team is going to lose a number 1 draft pick to overpay for him and sign him to a one year deal with an option for next year if he reaches certain goals. I know it costs money but Dolan needs to look at the big pitcher. Adding the pitcher with the best winning percentage in the NL last year to our weakest link would be a major upgrade. As it would allow us more depth.

You could start the year with Masterson-Lohse-Ubaldo-Meyers-Kazmir.

Have Carlos Carrasco and Zach McCallister just waiting to be called up. When 1 or 2 of those guys don't perform we have two young guys just waiting to take over. Not to mention young stud Trevor Bauer and depth option Corey Kluber. I believe out of all those arms we could find 5 that could give us an above average rotation.
March 8, 2013 - 2:01 PM EST
Swisher hitting well is nice to see, but as Francona said, that's expected. I think one of the more impressive performance so far this spring has been Chisenhall. Last year he had 1 BB and 16ks. So far this spring, 4 BBs and 3 Ks. That is very nice to see.

March 8, 2013 - 12:19 PM EST
I believe Tomlin was already DLed for Bourn, but if 3 NRIs make the team that should mean Carrera and Huff will not. Herrmann's DL will open the third spot.
March 8, 2013 - 12:00 PM EST
Yeah, Herrmann a definite candidate for 60-day DL and opens a spot on the 40-man for Kazmir or Raburn. Tomlin to go on 60-day DL to create spot for the other guy. Then just depends on if Giambi makes the team....which if he does it means that Carrera did not (and he takes Carrera's spot on the 40-man).
Western Canadian Select
March 8, 2013 - 11:56 AM EST
Sounds like Herrmann is toast. No big loss.
March 8, 2013 - 11:45 AM EST
McDade may end up as a solid depth pickup. He's pretty limited to just first base, so will be interesting if they try to add some versatility to his game. Will also be interesting to see what kind of chance he gets. He is not a big time prospect and may just be a 4A guy, but nice to have a few potential 1B options in the upper levels for once with McDade and Aguilar. Hopefully one pans out as a solid big leaguer.
Josh wegs
March 8, 2013 - 11:14 AM EST
love mccdade. he and aguilar are the future at first /dh

Your Name:
Leave a Comment:
Security Code: